How to Prevent Weld Cracking in S235J2W Corten Steel During Cold Weather Welding

Dec 31, 2025 Leave a message

Welding S235J2W weathering steel in cold weather is not limited by the base metal: the J2 designation under EN 10025-5 guarantees a minimum Charpy V-notch impact energy of 27 J at -20 degrees C. The difficulty lies in the weld itself. Low ambient temperature accelerates cooling, raises the hardness of the heat-affected zone, and traps hydrogen in the joint, which is the mechanism behind hydrogen-induced cold cracking that can appear hours after the arc has stopped.

The Three Conditions That Produce Cold Cracking

Cracking requires three factors to be present at the same time: a hard and crack-sensitive microstructure, tensile stress, and diffusible hydrogen. Removing any one of them prevents failure, while removing all three gives a weld that is safe for structural service. In cold weather all three become more likely at once, which is why a procedure that works in summer needs deliberate adjustment in winter.

Microstructure. Rapid cooling from the welding temperature produces martensite in the heat-affected zone, especially in thicker sections and in high-heat-input welds stopped early.

Stress. Restraint from a stiff joint or a thick plate adds residual stress as the weld contracts during cooling.

Hydrogen. Moisture on the plate, damp electrodes, condensation in the joint gap and humid air are all sources of diffusible hydrogen.

Step 1: Control the Consumables

The filler metal is the largest hydrogen source in most workshops. Use electrodes classified as low-hydrogen, typically H5 or better under EN ISO 2560-A or the equivalent American classification for covered electrodes, and keep them in a holding oven at 100-150 degrees C once the sealed container has been opened. Electrodes exposed to air for more than a few hours should be re-dried according to the manufacturer's instruction. A correctly stored H5 electrode is classified to deposit no more than 5 ml of diffusible hydrogen per 100 g of weld metal, the value that matters most at low ambient temperature.

For weathering steel, matching consumables that produce a weld metal with comparable alloy content are preferred, because a plain carbon steel deposit next to S235J2W weathers at a different rate and shows as a bright stripe on the finished structure.

Step 2: Preheat and Interpass Control

Preheating slows the cooling rate, which prevents the formation of a hard heat-affected zone and gives hydrogen time to diffuse out of the joint before the weld goes cold. For S235J2W the usual working range is 50-100 degrees C, with the upper end of that range used for thicker plate, higher restraint, and lower ambient temperature. Interpass temperature must never fall below the preheat value, and it must be measured rather than assumed: a contact thermocouple or an infrared thermometer should be used after each pass.

Parameter Normal climate Cold weather adjustment (below 5 degrees C)
Preheat As given in the welding procedure specification, may be minimal Increase by 25-50 degrees C above the minimum in the specification
Interpass temperature Maintained per procedure Measure after every pass and reheat if it drops
Ambient conditions General wind and weather protection Enclosed, heated shelter; base metal above 0 degrees C before striking an arc
Heat input Within the qualified range Avoid very low heat input, which hardens the heat-affected zone
Cooling Air cooling Insulating blanket for slow, controlled cool-down
Post-weld heat treatment Only if specified 550-600 degrees C stress relief for thick or highly restrained joints

Step 3: Manage the Welding Environment

Wind is the most damaging environmental factor on site because it removes heat from the molten pool far faster than still air and can double the cooling rate of a small fillet weld. Erect windbreaks and a tent or canopy around the joint, and check that the shelter also keeps rain and snow off the work: water on the plate introduces hydrogen into the arc and causes local thermal shock.

If the plate temperature is below 0 degrees C, warm the base metal with heating blankets until it is above the minimum preheat before any arc is struck.

Clean the joint of rust, moisture, paint and grease immediately before welding, and confirm that the surfaces are dry to the touch.

Keep the electrode warm between passes by returning it to the oven, and use a short exposure time for each electrode removed.

Record ambient temperature and plate temperature at the start of the shift and every two hours afterwards.

Step 4: Post-Weld Practice

The job does not end when the arc stops. Where post-weld heat treatment is specified, a controlled stress relief bake at 550-600 degrees C is the most effective way to drive out residual hydrogen and relax residual stress in thick or restrained joints. Where heat treatment is not required, wrap the finished weld in an insulating blanket instead of allowing it to cool in cold air, so that cooling proceeds gradually through the temperature range in which hydrogen embrittlement is most likely.

Inspect after 24 to 48 hours, because cold cracks are delayed by nature. Visual inspection of the toe and the cap, dye penetrant testing of the heat-affected zone, and ultrasonic testing of thick sections are the usual sequence, and any indication should be removed and re-welded with the preheat raised further.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why does S235J2W crack more easily in winter?
Low ambient temperature increases the cooling rate, which hardens the heat-affected zone and reduces the time available for hydrogen to escape. Both effects raise the risk of delayed cracking.

Q: Is preheating always required below 0 degrees C?
Preheat should always be applied when the base metal is below the minimum stated in the qualified procedure, and the plate itself must be warmed above 0 degrees C before the first pass in freezing conditions.

Q: What preheat temperature is typical for S235J2W?
A working range of 50-100 degrees C is common, with the upper part of the range used for thicker plate, higher restraint and colder ambient conditions.

Q: Can a damp electrode be dried and reused?
Electrodes that have picked up moisture can be re-dried once, following the manufacturer's stated temperature and time, but electrodes that are visibly damaged or have lost coating should be discarded.

Q: What is the purpose of post-weld heat treatment?
A controlled bake at 550-600 degrees C relieves residual stress and allows hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld and heat-affected zone, which greatly reduces the risk of delayed cracking.

Q: How soon should a weld be inspected for cracking?
Cold cracks often appear between 24 and 48 hours after welding, so final inspection should be scheduled after that delay rather than immediately after the weld has cooled.